How much will this cost me out of pocket?
On an insurance replacement, your out-of-pocket is normally just your deductible — whatever your policy lists, often $1,000 to $2,500 for wind and hail. The insurer pays the rest at replacement cost minus depreciation up front, then releases the depreciation when the job is finished and invoiced. A repair small enough to fall under your deductible you'd pay for yourself; those run a few hundred dollars for a section of shingles up to a couple thousand for flashing and valley work. We tell you which side of the deductible you're on before you file.
How soon can you get the work done?
The inspection usually happens within a couple of days of your call. The install itself is one to two days for a typical Cleveland house. The wait in between is the claim — filing, the adjuster visit, and approval — which runs anywhere from one to four weeks depending on your carrier and how busy they are after a widespread storm. If the roof is actively leaking the crew tarps it the same visit so the delay doesn't cost you a ceiling.
Should I file a claim, or just pay for it?
File when the damage is real storm damage and clearly more than your deductible — a hail-bruised roof or wind that took out a slope. Don't file for normal wear, an old worn-out roof, or a small repair under your deductible; a denied or withdrawn claim still sits on your record. The contractor inspects first, and we'll tell you honestly which it is. A weather claim generally won't single you out for a rate increase the way an at-fault claim does, but we won't push you to file something that isn't there.
What shingles will you put on?
Almost always architectural (dimensional) asphalt shingles — they're the standard here, handle the heat and wind better than the old three-tab, and carry a Class 3 or 4 impact rating on the better lines. In this climate the algae-resistant versions are worth it to slow the black streaking. Insurance pays to replace what you had with like kind, so if you had three-tab you get architectural in the same class. Metal is an option if you want it, but it's an upgrade you'd pay the difference on.
What does your workmanship warranty actually cover?
Two different warranties are in play. The manufacturer covers defects in the shingle itself, typically prorated material after the first years. The contractor's workmanship warranty covers the install — the leaks that come from a mistake they made, like a botched flashing or valley or a nail in the wrong place. That's the one that matters, because most roof leaks are installation, not the shingle. It doesn't cover the next hailstorm; that's a new claim. Get the terms in writing and make sure the company will still be here to honor them.
Do I have to replace the whole roof if only one slope got hit?
Not always, but often the honest answer is yes. If hail bruised one slope, the shingles that match it are the same age and dried out across the whole roof, and a repair on a 15-year-old roof rarely blends or seals right. Insurers will sometimes pay for a single slope, and they'll do that when it's the right call. But patching one side of a worn roof usually just moves the next leak a few feet over, and you end up paying twice.